November 1, 2026
A straight answer to the question nobody in commercial real estate wants to answer.
Every proposal I send includes this article, because the conversation about fees is usually the shortest and least honest part of hiring a broker. The owner asks "what's your rate," the broker says a number, and nobody talks about where that money goes or what it buys. That's a mistake, and it's a mistake that costs owners real money at closing.
So here's the full explanation. This is everything I'd tell you on a call about commissions, written down so you can read it twice and check my math.
Start with the house
At a large national brokerage, an agent typically starts on a 50/50 split. Half of every commission dollar goes to the company. That number improves with production and tenure, but it never goes away.
Don't take my word for it. The largest publicly traded investment sales brokerage in the country, 80-plus offices, files its financials with the SEC. In 2025, cost of services, which is what they pay their agents, was 62.3% of revenue. That means roughly 38 cents of every commission dollar stayed with the house, and that figure is blended across their most senior, most productive brokers. Junior agents give up more.
Same firm, same year: $755 million in revenue, $769 million in operating expenses.
The biggest investment sales shop in the country spent more than it made.
Here's why that matters to you. The 38 to 50 cents that stays with the house pays for downtown office space, management salaries, shareholder returns, and a corporate structure built to serve multifamily, retail, office, land, leasing, property management, and a dozen other service lines. None of that helps your RV park, campground, mobile home community, or marina sell for one dollar more. When you hire a big firm, you are fully reliant on the individual agent, not the firm.
I can say that with some confidence because I've worked at a national firm with over 80 offices and 2,000-plus agents, at a global firm with offices in multiple countries, and at a multi-state regional firm. The larger the firm, the less specialized the resources, because leadership is building tools that have to be shared across every service line. In practice that means agents at big firms are often paying for their own marketing deliverables, their own CRM, and their own support staff out of their own cut. The house always gets paid first.
Walk the money through a real deal
Say your property generates a $100,000 commission at a national firm.
- If an outside buyer's broker is involved, roughly half goes to them. $50,000 left.
- The house takes its split of what remains. Call it $25,000 left.
- If your agent is on a team, the senior broker takes a cut of that. The person who cold-called you, usually the youngest member of the team who spends the most hours on the phone, nets somewhere between $10,000 and $25,000 on your $100,000 commission.
Now follow that to its conclusion. If an agent nets $25,000 per closing, they need eight closings a year to make a living. That means eight to twelve listings in flight at any given time. On a good day, your property is getting one tenth of that agent's attention. They are never working on your deal exclusively, because the math won't let them.
The two ways a big-firm agent makes up the difference
For an agent at a national firm to earn what our agents earn, one of two things has to be true:
They charge you a higher fee.
We know agents at other firms who have charged 10% on deals where our standard fee would have been 4.5%. Same asset, same price point. The extra fee isn't buying you more service. It's covering the house's share so the agent still takes home a living.
They do more deals.
More deals means less time per deal. Your listing becomes one of twelve instead of one of three.
Neither of those outcomes is good for you. You either pay above market for your agent's model, or you get a smaller slice of their time. Most owners end up with some of both.
What North Star does differently
North Star is privately owned and built exclusively for outdoor hospitality. We have no shareholders to appease and no downtown tower to fill. Our commission structure is built around a different question: what does it take to sell this property well?
Our agents can earn up to 80% of the total commission. That's not generosity. It's incentive design. An agent who keeps 80 cents on the dollar can afford to put real time and attention on your individual deal, because each closing is worth more to them. The volume ideology that big firms run on, where the agent survives by stacking listings, isn't necessary here.
That's why we can charge less. Our fees run from 1% to 6% depending on size and complexity, and we sign 30-day exclusive listing agreements instead of the 6 to 12 month exclusives common at national firms. A shorter agreement keeps the pressure on us, not you.
And here's the part the big firms can't replicate: we can charge the client less, give the agent more, and still fund a full team behind every listing, because the money that would have gone to management salaries and shareholder returns goes into the deal instead.
What that team looks like
When you hire North Star you're not hiring one person. You're hiring:
An in-house transaction coordinator who has only ever worked on these types of deals. Title, survey, estoppels, permits and license transfers, utility accounts, lease assignments, lender conditions. The 60 to 90 days after the LOI that most owners never see, handled by a specialist.
A COO whose entire job is making sure the company runs and functions operationally, so deals don't stall because the person managing them is also chasing their next listing.
A data management team whose sole job is tracking our markets: every property and who owns it, every listing, every closing, every off-market trade, who bought, who sold, who brokered it, and how it was financed. That's how our clients get better information to make better decisions.
A specialized marketing team that only markets outdoor hospitality properties. Offering memorandums, deal rooms, and buyer distribution built for this asset class.
Polaris, our proprietary buyer database, built over years of exclusively working these transactions. On our closings, 60 to 70% of the buyers who end up purchasing were already in our system before the property hit the market.
Every agent in the company, each of whom can bring buyers to your deal and earn a commission on it. More on that below.
Every seat is held by a specialist in outdoor hospitality. Nothing in the building competes with your deal for attention.
Contrast that with how most agents at most firms operate: solo, or as part of a small team. To succeed, that agent has to do their own outbound prospecting, generate new business, underwrite, pitch, win the listing, run buyer engagement, and coordinate the transaction. All of it. So one of two things is true. Either they're pouring time into your transaction at the expense of their pipeline, which is what you'd want but isn't sustainable for them. Or, far more likely, they're juggling your deal alongside several others. The percentage of brokers who are excellent at business development, underwriting, buyer engagement, and escrow management all at once is very small. The attention your deal gets is lower by default.
The clause that quietly shrinks your buyer pool
This is the part of the commission conversation that almost nobody explains, and it may be the most expensive line in your listing agreement.
Almost every other firm operating in our market puts a provision in the confidentiality agreement they make buyers sign, stating that no outside broker commission will be paid. The result is that most brokers won't pursue those deals. And that's the intent.
Brokers don't want other brokers bringing buyers to their deal, because it costs them a tremendous amount of money. On a 6% fee, if the listing broker controls the buyer too, they keep the whole 6%. The moment an outside broker enters, they're down to 3%. Halving your own income is a powerful motive to keep other brokers out.
Here's what that does to you. Every broker in the market with a buyer relationship is de-incentivized from bringing that buyer to your property. The listing broker just locked your deal away from every network except their own.
A recent example. A property in our market was listed not long ago by a firm with this exact clause in writing. Within days, three separate buyers called me asking whether it was worth pursuing and whether I'd help them analyze it so they could make an offer. These are buyers who want me on their side because I've closed more of these transactions than almost anyone, and that experience is worth real money to them. I told every one of them the same thing: no, I can't spend time on this. The listing brokers had put in writing that I would not be entitled to a commission, even if I represented the buyer.
So where did those three buyers go? To deals where I could earn something, including my own listings. That's not spite. That's the only rational response to the structure. And the owner of that property will never know about three qualified buyers who were ready to engage.
And when the buyer brings their broker anyway, you still pay
Say one of those buyers insists on having me involved. Now they have to pay my commission on top of the purchase price. That doesn't mean the buyer pays more for the property. It means they adjust their offer down by the amount of my fee. The money comes out of your proceeds either way, exactly as if the commission had been paid on the seller's side.
The only difference is who wins. Your listing broker still collects their full commission. The buyer's broker is usually making no less than 3%, and that 3% got priced into a lower offer. So instead of paying 6%, you end up paying closer to 9%, and your own broker made a huge cut at the expense of the owner they were supposed to represent.
North Star always co-brokes, and we always pay the outside broker. Our fee structure is tiered to make that work: if an outside broker brings the buyer, the fee is the full rate and the outside broker shares in it. If there's no outside broker, the fee drops and you keep the difference. Either way, every network in the market has a reason to point buyers at your property.
That's a big part of why our assignments average 9.6 offers per sold deal in the first 60 days of marketing. And it's why, 79% of the time that we sell a property, the person who ends up buying it from us is identified in the first 60 days of marketing. Widest buyer pool, fastest, while your property is new to the market.
Why the best brokers leave the big firms
If the top producers at national firms are paying 38 cents on the dollar for office space and management overhead, why don't they leave?
The best ones do. Look around the market. Top producers go start their own shops, because at some point they realize the clients belong to them, not the firm.
But that creates the other failure mode. The solo broker who left is now one person with no team behind your listing. No transaction coordinator, no marketing department, no buyer engagement process, no network of colleagues working your deal.
The model that works is the one where the producer keeps the client relationship and the firm builds the machine behind it. That's what North Star is. Agents at big firms can build teams like ours, but the team comes out of their cut, not the house's, so they build the smallest team they can get away with. Usually none.
The short version
- At a national firm, 38 to 50 cents of every commission dollar goes to overhead that does nothing for your sale.
- To make a living inside that model, an agent either charges you more or spreads themselves thinner. Both cost you.
- North Star agents earn up to 80%, which lets us charge less, provide more, and keep real attention on your deal.
- Every listing gets a specialist transaction coordinator, a COO, a data management team, a dedicated marketing team, a proprietary buyer database, and every agent in the firm working it.
- Most firms refuse to pay outside brokers. That shrinks your buyer pool, and when a buyer's broker shows up anyway, you end up paying closer to 9%. We always co-broke.
If your current broker's confidentiality agreement has a "no outside commission" clause in it, go ask them why. Then schedule a call with us.
Schedule a CallPrevious Post
The New Manufactured Housing Task Force: What It Means for MH Community Owners, Sellers and Buyers
Next Post
Why Big Brands Are Buying Glamping Properties, and What It Means for Your Exit